Transatlantic Relations

Learn from History or Lose

With neither Trump nor Harris clear on their national security views, looking at the past of US-European relations helps in projecting the future.

John Bolton is an American diplomat, attorney, and political commentator. 
John Bolton is an American diplomat, attorney, and political commentator. Alexander Mahmoud / TT News Agency / picturedesk.com

Divining the future of European-American relations is particularly difficult when so many Western nations face contentious, rapidly changing domestic politics. In America, the one certainty is that there will be a new president on January 20, 2025, although we cannot confidently predict who. Since neither Donald Trump nor Kamala Harris have clear national security views, the prospect is for more confusion and disarray. Recent European elections have also produced inconclusive results, with more ahead. In such circumstances, taking a longer view of recent US-European relations may tell us more than speculating about transitory election results. A convenient starting point is the West’s victory in the Cold War. Today, few remember the Cold War theory of “convergence,” which held that communism and capitalism would gradually grow more alike, with peaceful relations emerging as socio-economic systems shed many differences. In short, pro-convergence advocates saw a world not too hot and not too cold, but just one large, happy social democracy.